Trang chủInternational FootballCuti Romero Calls for the Ballon d'Or for Messi: A Defender Speaks, and the Votes of 100 Journalists

Cuti Romero Calls for the Ballon d'Or for Messi: A Defender Speaks, and the Votes of 100 Journalists

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi:** Cristian "Cuti" Romero, trung vệ Tottenham Hotspur và đội tuyển Argentina, công khai kêu gọi trao Quả bóng Vàng cho Lionel Messi với lý do "không có ai như anh ấy". Huấn luyện viên Diego Simeone ủng hộ quan điểm này sau trận derby Madrid, nơi Atlético đánh bại Real Madrid. **Dữ kiện chính:** - Romero (Tottenham, Argentina) nói Messi xứng đáng Quả bóng Vàng: "Không có ai như anh ấy". - Simeone (Atlético de Madrid) tuyên bố Messi phải thắng giải, nhấn mạnh màn trình diễn World Cup "ở cái tuổi anh ấy đang có". - Atlético đánh bại Real Madrid tại Metropolitano — bối cảnh thời điểm các phát biểu được đưa ra. - Trang nhất L'Équipe xếp Messi trong nhóm năm ứng viên hàng đầu; có ý kiến cho rằng Rodri bị bỏ sót khỏi danh sách. - Quả bóng Vàng do France Football (Groupe Amaury) tổ chức; 100 nhà báo bỏ phiếu theo thang điểm 6-4-3-2-1. **Nguồn:** Phát ngôn trực tiếp của Cristian Romero và Diego Simeone trong khu vực phỏng vấn sau trận derby Madrid; dữ liệu World Cup đối chiếu hồ sơ FIFA. Một số chỉ số trong bản gốc tiếng nước ngoài không khớp hồ sơ chính thức. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan:** - Hỏi: Messi đã ghi bao nhiêu bàn tại World Cup? Đáp: 13 bàn sau 26 trận qua 5 kỳ World Cup từ 2006 đến 2022, theo hồ sơ FIFA. - Hỏi: Ai bỏ phiếu Quả bóng Vàng? Đáp: 100 nhà báo từ các quốc gia có thứ hạng FIFA cao nhất, mỗi người chọn 5 cầu thủ theo thang 6-4-3-2-1, do France Football tổ chức. - Hỏi: Vì sao Rodri được nhắc tới trong tranh cãi? Đáp: Một dòng phản biện cho rằng tiền vệ này bị bỏ sót khỏi danh sách, nhưng chưa được France Football xác nhận chính thức.

Cristian "Cuti" Romero, the Tottenham Hotspur and Argentina centre-back, has said something I have heard dozens of times across more than forty years of writing about football: the Ballon d'Or must go to Lionel Messi.

"There is no one like him," he added, as calmly as if restating a fact everyone already accepts.

What made me stop was not the content but the speaker. A defender. A man who earns his living destroying what forwards create, standing up to campaign for an individual award belonging to a forward — when he is the one who has spent sleepless nights dealing with players like that. Defenders are the quietest group in football. They speak little and praise less. When a centre-back speaks up, it usually means he could no longer stay silent.

In my drawer, there are football notes older than the internet. I write them in pencil, because ink smudges when it rains in the stands. Among those papers is a rule I have tracked since 2026: Ballon d'Or campaigns are almost always launched by compatriots, and almost never by the people who actually vote.

Today's story sits squarely inside that rule. It has one extra layer: a defender speaking on behalf of a No. 10, with an entire national belief system behind him.

Context: three leagues, one flag

Messi plays for Inter Miami in MLS. Romero plays for Tottenham in the Premier League. Diego Simeone manages Atlético de Madrid in La Liga. Three leagues, three time zones, three media systems — and the same flag. When those three voices speak about the Ballon d'Or at the same moment, what is produced is no longer individual opinion. It is a wave.

The mechanism bears repeating, because many fans argue about the Ballon d'Or without knowing who votes. The award is organised by France Football, part of Groupe Amaury, which also owns the newspaper L'Équipe. One hundred journalists from the hundred highest-ranked FIFA nations vote, each selecting five players on a 6-4-3-2-1 scale. The ballots are not cast in Buenos Aires. They are cast across the world, in newsrooms where people stay up until three in the morning for the Champions League and rarely switch on MLS.

The story's anchor in time is the mixed zone after the Madrid derby at the Metropolitano, where Atlético beat Real Madrid. Simeone — who had just beaten the club of Kylian Mbappé — declared that Messi must win, "without any doubt," with a striking argument: "After the World Cup he had, at the age he has."

Elsewhere, L'Équipe's front page placed Messi among the top five candidates. And inside the same wave came a counter-current: several names were missing from the list, including Rodri.

Four fragments. One question I always ask before any tribute piece: which part is data, and which part is emotion?

A Ballon d'Or ballot is a geographical ballot first

A journalist in Senegal, a journalist in Norway and a journalist in Japan have three entirely different viewing habits, but they share one thing: they see the Champions League, the Euros, the Copa América and the World Cup. What happens in MLS at two in the morning European time is usually outside their field of vision. That is a structural disadvantage, and no tribute can erase it.

History makes this fairly clear. In 2026, Wesley Sneijder won the treble with Inter Milan and reached the World Cup final with the Netherlands, yet finished fourth — behind Messi, Andrés Iniesta and Xavi. In 2026, Luka Modrić won after lifting the Champions League with Real Madrid and reaching the World Cup final. In 2026, Fabio Cannavaro became the last defender to win, after Italy's World Cup triumph; nearly two decades later, no defender has repeated it.

Those three cases say the same thing: the jury rewards achievements visible on European television and in an international tournament of recognised difficulty. Messi at Inter Miami has no Champions League. He has World Cup 2026 — still weighty in the eyes of voters, but receding further into the past with every month.

There is one more case, closer to today's story than any other. In 2026, Virgil van Dijk won the Champions League with Liverpool, was named UEFA's best player, and most of the European media believed he would take the Ballon d'Or. Messi won with 686 points; Van Dijk had 679. A seven-point margin. Those seven points came from journalists who do not live in Europe — people who saw what their European colleagues missed.

That is why I do not trust quick conclusions. Seven points can be created by a voting bloc nobody is watching.

Reading a match by position, not by scoreline

At 66, I no longer read football through scorelines. I read it through positions.

I spent three evenings last week rewatching the 2026 World Cup final, the eleventh time in more than three years. Messi's 108th-minute goal came from a phase of play in which he barely moved: Lautaro Martínez shot, Hugo Lloris parried, and Messi was the only man in the box standing in the right place to convert the rebound. That is the instinct of a No. 9, not of a playmaking midfielder.

Then the 69th minute of the semi-final against Croatia: he collected the ball on the right flank, went past Joško Gvardiol — the tournament's most highly rated defender — and cut it back for Julián Álvarez. A phase of play by a man past 35, doing something the youngest defenders could not react to.

Those two moments explain why a centre-back like Romero speaks on his behalf. Defenders understand best the value of the man who makes them feel helpless. A tactical diagram is only a sheet of paper; the players are the ones who write the match.

But there is something every tribute skips: Messi has been protected in every system he has played. At the 2026 World Cup, Rodrigo De Paul, Enzo Fernández and Leandro Paredes did the running he did not do. At Inter Miami, he operates as a free No. 10, rarely pressing, allowed to stand still between the lines and wait for the ball. This is a tactical fact, not a criticism. But it means his final output depends on a machine built around him. When assessing a player individually, voters must decide whether they are rewarding the player or the system that assembled him.

And that is where the data starts to wobble.

Opening the drawer and checking

Several circulating translations of this story carry details that do not match the official record. One states that Messi has "12 assists and 21 goals" in World Cups. FIFA's record shows Messi scoring 13 goals in 26 World Cup matches across five tournaments from 2026 to 2026. His World Cup assist tally is also well below twelve.

Another version places Romero in Atlético de Madrid's squad, when his club is Tottenham Hotspur. A third says Messi is entering his sixth World Cup, when he has played five: 2026, 2026, 2026, 2026 and 2026.

None of those three errors collapses the story. But they say something important: most Ballon d'Or content is recycled through several layers of translation, and each layer adds a little noise. When a wrong figure is repeated enough times, it becomes the basis of an argument; and when the argument is repeated enough times, it becomes collective belief that nobody checks any more.

Based on my experience tracking matches across these cycles, this is the most dangerous signal in the whole story — more dangerous than whether Messi wins.

The MLS calendar does not match the ballot calendar

Here is a detail almost nobody mentions, and it is more systemic than any tribute. Since 2026, France Football has assessed the award over the European season, running from August to July. MLS runs from February to October, with playoffs stretching into November and December.

The consequence is concrete: Messi's best stretches in the United States fall into a period split between two ballots, where the tail of one season belongs to the previous vote and the start of the next belongs to the one after. Nobody does this deliberately. But the structure is unfavourable in itself, and a player in MLS always pays for his own league's calendar.

This is the kind of analysis I want to see in award coverage, instead of tribute paragraphs copied from one place to another. Mechanism determines outcomes. Emotion determines headlines.

The Argentine network and the limits of soft power

Then there is the Argentine network. Romero in London. Simeone in Madrid. Messi in Miami. Three media centres, one voice. European football has seen similar networks: Spain's 2026 generation with Xavi, Iniesta and Iker Casillas; Brazil's generation with Ronaldinho and Kaká. The defining trait of a network is that nobody has to issue orders. Each member says what he genuinely believes, and because they believe the same thing, the sounds add up into a declaration.

But it must be said plainly: that is the soft power of a football nation, not technical evidence. And the Ballon d'Or ballot is cast by people outside that network.

In the statements on record, Romero added one detail I consider the most important of all: Messi helped him a great deal to adapt to the national team, and he has called Messi his idol since he was very young. At the same time, he described giving Messi the Ballon d'Or as "a nice farewell."

A nice farewell. Those three words place the entire story in its true context: this is an honour aimed at the past, delivered in the language of the present. There is nothing wrong with that. But voters are asked to assess a season, not a career.

Rodri, and the counter-line written in faint ink

The counter-line about Rodri is the most valuable item in the whole story, and unfortunately the faintest.

Rodri is the type of player modern ballots struggle to evaluate: a holding midfielder who does not score, does not assist, but sets the tempo of an entire team. He belongs to the group most mentioned by coaches and least mentioned by media. A list missing him deserves questioning on criteria, not on emotion.

And here is a point about reading skill worth stating clearly: L'Équipe is a newspaper, France Football is the award's organiser. Both sit under Groupe Amaury, but a ranking L'Équipe compiles is not the official Ballon d'Or shortlist. When media conflate the two, an editorial prediction is suddenly presented as a nomination. Readers should know which document they are holding before quoting it as a fact.

I have seen this confusion hundreds of times. It never causes immediate damage. It just quietly erodes trust in an award that has already endured enough controversy.

The execution blind spot: when every voice is on one side

Beneath all the noise lies a blind spot neither Romero nor Simeone can see: every tribute to Messi in this story comes from an Argentine.

Romero is a compatriot. Simeone is a compatriot. The wave, however sincere, remains testimony from an interested party. In source-evaluation practice, such statements are systematically downgraded. They are true for the speaker; they are not necessarily true for the listener.

The more dangerous blind spot lies in the campaign's own dynamics. The more supporting voices there are, the higher expectations are pushed; and if the ballot goes the other way, the reaction will match the height it was pushed to. I have seen this pattern at least three times in my career: a flawless media campaign turning into a shield for the very man it meant to protect.

One blind spot belongs to Vietnamese readers themselves. In countries with strong football cultures, readers meet both sides of the story directly. Here, most Ballon d'Or content arrives through several layers of translation, usually keeping the praise and discarding the rebuttal. The result is a portrait with only half a face — and fans arguing with the other half they have never seen.

In this particular case, the discarded half contains three data errors, one wrong club name, and one unconfirmed list. None is large enough to destroy the story. But all are large enough to remind us that collective belief can be built on bricks nobody inspected.

What to verify when the next ballot opens

What I want to know at the next vote is not who wins. I want to know how many of those hundred journalists actually watch MLS weekly, and how many know Messi only through pre-cut goal clips online. If the second group dominates, then football's most prestigious individual award is being decided by people who have never seen the winner in an ordinary state.

And if that is true, the real debate is not Messi versus Rodri, but what we want the award to measure — a season gone by, or a collective memory the whole world shares.

The new generation reads matches through screens. I read them through the breath of the stands. Both approaches have blind spots, and both will be tested when the ballots are opened.

A good rule never exists to punish. It exists to protect beauty.